Blind Peer Review Criteria
The Editorial Board of Filanderas. Revista Interdisciplinar de Estudios Feministas subjects the articles received for the ‘Estudios’ and 'Ensayos' section to a blind peer review and firmly guarantees their anonymity. This assessment is carried out by professionals in the discipline to which the text belongs, whose judgement is not influenced by subjective factors or factors that are not strictly intellectual or academic.
The reviewer, bearing in mind the characteristics of the journal, must give his/her opinion on the following questions:
- Fit with the journal's profile and integration of a feminist perspective.
- Originality and relevance of the approach.
- Accuracy of the conceptual and methodological frameworks.
- Appropriateness to current scientific trends in the field of knowledge.
- Accuracy and clarity of the presentation.
- Academic structure and internal coherence (hypothesis, argumentation, conclusions).
- Relevant and up-to-date bibliography in the field of knowledge.
These opinions must be impersonally motivated so that they can be transmitted, even if not literally, to the author by the Editorial Committee, particularly in the case of a rejection or a request for modification of the text submitted to the journal. In the latter case, it would be appreciated if the aspects to be developed or corrected, and the reasons for doing so, were specified as clearly as possible.
